#931: Speculation rules: target_hint field
Discussions
2024-05-20
adding assignments
Matthew: it says "for implementation reasons" and also "we want to get rid of this in future" - so how many people are going to use it given that they want to get rid of it and what does that mean for the dev tools. When we've looked at others of these we've wanted a bit more detail on when and how it's gonna be deprecated.
Dan: links to a fragment of speculation rules explainer but no specific user needs..
Dan: adds comment and Matthew will add another comment about deprecation.
also we assign Tess as another reviewer
2024-08-19
Amy: no response to our requests for more info in the explainer
Peter: I'll ask for updates
2024-09-09
Tess: looks like ... jeffrey asked some questions ... could mark as pending ex feedback?
Jeffrey: I'm assuming they will say it's gonna take a year... Totally possible it will be a constraint for webkit and mozilla also ... only concern I saw is maybe this shows that mozilla is right ... to use anchor tags...
Tess: I think micro-syntax ... knee-jerk reaction is .. we won't need it.
Jeffrey: moz's approach is to design a different micro-syntax... Not obviously better. The comment might be 'please keep working with moz to see what the right syntax is'.
Tess: that would work for me. We could close it now...
Jeffrey: this is a real small tweak to bigger pre-rendering issue.
Tess: this has arch implications because it's redundantly specifying...
<blockquote>Please keep working with Mozilla to figure out the right syntax for this, especially whether the need for target
information reinforces their preference to re-use <a> elements. Beyond that, we don't see any architectural issues and (ignoring any worries about the underlying feature) are satisfied
with this extension.
We agree to close.
OpenedFeb 13, 2024
こんにちは TAG-さん!
I'm requesting a TAG review of
target_hint
field for speculation rules prerendering.This extends speculation rules syntax to allow developers to specify the
target_hint
field.This field provides a hint to indicate a target navigable where a prerendered page will eventually be activated. For example, when
_blank
is specified as a hint, a prerendered page can be activated for a navigable opened bywindow.open()
. The field has no effect on prefetching.Further details:
You should also know that...
n/a
We'd prefer the TAG provide feedback as (please delete all but the desired option):
☂️ open a single issue in our GitHub repo for the entire review