#713: Review request for Confirmation of Action API
Discussions
Discussed
Feb 1, 2022 (See Github)
punted to next week
Discussed
Feb 1, 2022 (See Github)
Dan: this starts off with user need which is great.
Dan: Regarding the privacy & security questions - do we think it should be restricted to secure contexts?
Sangwhan: given how easy it is to get https certs not sure it will mitigate against misuse. The other part that concerns me -
Dan: shouldn't this be the same bar as push notification API?
Sangwhan: gate it behind a permission?
Dan: I don't see the argument ...
Sangwhan: not convinced that it makes it less dangerous .. i won't lose sleep.
[...side discussion on secure contexts...]
Sangwhan: I'm more concerned about will applications be too chatty? other potential issue - aria so far has been declarartive - this is an API that changes that paradigm...
Dan: it's in the AOM work - so associated with other technologies that do the same...
Hi @sartang - thanks for this really well-written explainer! We especially appreciate how it starts with the user needs. Do you have any further info on multi-stakeholder interest? Have they had feedback from the ARIA community on this?
Dan & Sangwhan to have side discussions
Comment by @torgo Feb 15, 2022 (See Github)
Hi @sartang - thanks for this really well-written explainer! We especially appreciate how it starts with the user needs. Do you have any further info on multi-stakeholder interest? Have they had feedback from the ARIA community on this?
Comment by @sartang Mar 4, 2022 (See Github)
@torgo Not at the moment, but we are hoping to get more feedback once we start prototyping.
Comment by @dlibby- Mar 8, 2022 (See Github)
As @sartang mentioned, we're planning on getting more feedback from other stakeholders as we refine the proposal during implementation and modification to the proposal.
We have received some preliminary feedback from various folks (see initial discussion in the AOM CG and https://github.com/WICG/aom/issues/187), and once we believe we've addressed that feedback, we plan on opening this up for discussion in ARIA WG.
cc @travisleithead in case he wanted to add any details.
Comment by @LeaVerou Mar 23, 2022 (See Github)
Hi there,
We looked at this today during our F2F. Overall this looks like useful functionality that has been missing from the web platform. We'd love to see this moving forward. Thanks for working with us!
Comment by @sartang Nov 29, 2023 (See Github)
Leaving a note here that I've updated the explainer. The proposal is largely the same, but more code examples have been added and the parameter names in the spec have changed slightly.
OpenedFeb 2, 2022
Braw mornin' TAG!
I'm requesting a TAG review of a Confirmation of Action API.
ARIA live regions are the only mechanism available today that communicate content changes down to the accessibility layer so that users can hear about them. ARIA live regions are stretched far beyond their original use cases as authors struggle to use them in scenarios that they weren't designed for. We propose a notification API purpose-built to communicate to the accessibility layer for scenarios in which ARIA live regions are a poor choice. One of these scenarios is a "confirmation of action" where the action in question is not necessarily tied to UI (elements) in the app.
Further details:
We'd prefer the TAG provide feedback as (please delete all but the desired option):
💬 leave review feedback as a comment in this issue and @-notify [sartang, dlibby]