#1008: Vision for W3C: request horizontal architectural review and wide TAG review
Discussions
Log in to see TAG-private discussions.
Discussed
Nov 1, 2024 (See Github)
Jeffrey: they would like comments by next week.
Matthew: when APA looked at it... we did't have a11y-specific things... but it's hard to see how this can be translated into actionable... I think it's ok for it to be high level but if you can't imagine how it can be actioned then it's difficult. So being a bit more positive / action oriented is a good thing.
Jeffrey: I don't want to block it from being published until it's perfect.
Martin: I think this document misses the thing that W3C provides : technical competence in developing standards. This document ignores that. So I'm not happy with it. The entire basis for credibility is that it produces technical standards...
Amy: vision for w3c section ... I think we could capture what Martin suggested .. technical and credibility...
Yves: considering who is working on it - I think it's better to send them an issue rather than a PR - that keeps the ownership of the text.
Jeffrety: that's fine with me...
Dan: let's agree our comment by next week - meantime I will have a back-channel discussion to give them a heads-up.
Discussed
Nov 1, 2024 (See Github)
we go through potential TAG feedback to the proposed W3C Vision with Tantek
we make progress on our consolidated feedback and agree with Tantek to file some issues and leave additional feedback soon
Drafting a comment in https://docs.google.com/document/d/1bqQ1vSO2NP94mF43Pj_MSMD20OJcdHhV5rgz5w3ihXs/edit?tab=t.0
Comment by @jyasskin Nov 22, 2024 (See Github)
We're going to need more time to finish our review. We currently have some draft points, which we're going to file as individual issues in https://github.com/w3c/AB-public/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+label%3A%22Project+Vision%22, and then we're planning to find TAG consensus on how serious they are by Dec 5.
OpenedOct 24, 2024
こんにちは TAG-さん!
I'm requesting a TAG review of Vision for W3C, which does not contain any technical features, thus any fields below relating to technical features or technical implementation have been marked N/A.
The W3C Vision articulates W3C’s mission, what W3C is, what it does and why that matters, and the values and principles by which it operates and makes decisions.
Further details:
You should also know that...
This document builds on the basis of the Technical Architecture Group’s excellent Ethical Web Principles. It is not intended to supplant that work nor redefine it, but fit into the same framework and promote many of the same goals.